skip to main |
skip to sidebar
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA - Metro Transit said Friday that it inadvertently sent the wrong message about tolerance in trying to accommodate a bus driver's religious objections to driving buses that carried gay-themed ads.
Metro Transit spokesman Bob Gibbons said the company made a temporary accommodation to the driver on Oct. 12, allowing her not drive buses that carried an ad for Lavender, a local magazine aimed at the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered community.
The ad showed the face of a young man with the slogan, "Unleash Your Inner Gay." Fifty buses carried it periodically.
The ad contract ran only through Oct. 18, Gibbons said, and buses no longer are carrying the ads.
However, in reviewing the issue, Gibbons said the company likely would not make the same decision again.
"We are not persuaded that advertising, per se, infringes on religious practices and would be reluctant to make similar accommodations in the future," Gibbons said.
The woman is still driving for Metro Transit, he added.
Metro Transit had come under fire from a union leader and some other drivers, who said the company was condoning intolerance.
"We deeply regret any impressions of intolerance," Gibbons said in a written statement. "Metro Transit employs and serves a diverse population, and we do our best to be respectful of all views."
The bus controversy followed news of many Muslim taxi drivers serving the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport refusing to accept passengers carrying alcohol and some pharmacists across the country insisting on the right to refuse to fill contraceptive prescriptions.
from The Pioneer Press
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA - The back of the bus was once a synonym for racial discrimination. This week, something on the back of some buses has become an issue of religious discrimination. The "something" is a billboard-type advertisement that appeared on the back of a number of Metro Transit buses for one week.
"It's very innocuous," Lavender Magazine owner and President Stephen Rocheford insists. The ad simply showed the face of a young man with the slogan "Unleash your inner gay", then directed people to the magazine's Web site.
Rocheford shrugged, "We knew just having the word "gay" on it was controversial to some people."
The ad for the gay-lesbian-bisexual and transgender oriented monthly magazine was more than controversial for one Metro Transit bus driver. "She came forward and said that the ad offended her religious beliefs," explained transit company spokesman Bob Gibbons.
Gibbons said they decided to accommodate the driver. She was reassigned to buses that did not have the Lavender ad. Gibbons said such accommodation is on a "case by case" basis.
"And you say to yourself, can you make a reasonable accommodation? If the answer to that is yes, the second question is does it cause you a business hardship? If the answer to that is yes, it does cause a business hardship, no accommodation would be made," said Gibbons.
Charles Sameulson of the American Civil Liberties Union of Minnesota sees the issue differently. "There is a sense in this society, that it's okay to refuse to be offended." As for Metro Transit's "accommodation"? "I think you just say I'm sorry, you have to drive the bus that's assigned to you."
Samuelson argues that public workers like bus drivers, taxi cab drivers, pharmacists and doctors have certain obligations that go with the job. "People who have occupational licenses, granted to them by the state, cannot discriminate."
Lavender owner Rocheford said freedom of religion is an important factor in American life, but it has some limits. "It does not allow people who work for organizations that get 54 - 55 percent of their funds from the public to decide whether they want to perform their job."
Interestingly, the driver's bargaining unit, local 1005 of the Amalgamated Transit Workers, did not side with their member. Union officials said making such accommodations based on religious objections could cause havoc with the bus system. What, one official wondered, would happen if a number of drivers objected to liquor ads or other advertising on religious grounds?
State Senator Scott Dibble was pleased to hear the union's take on the issue and he called on the Metropolitan Council and Transit officials to reverse their decision, "This is an outrageous decision. As a community, we should promote tolerance."
Dibble is a member of the Senate's Transportation Committee and has been a strong advocate for transit initiatives, but he said in a statement, "It is difficult for me to go to my constituents and ask their support for transit initiatives this fall.. When Metro Transit officials take such divisive actions."
Metro Transit called union officials into a meeting Wednesday afternoon to discuss the situation. The transit provider said it is reviewing its policy about such objections by drivers.
They may need to. Lavender Magazine intends to put more ads on Metro buses next spring.
from KARE 11 TV
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA - Metro Transit said Friday that it inadvertently sent the wrong message about tolerance in trying to accommodate a bus driver's religious objections to driving buses that carried gay-themed ads.